German GAAP (Handelsgesetzbuch – HGB) vs. IFRS: Understanding Germany’s Accounting Framework

Germany’s accounting and commercial law, embodied in the Handelsgesetzbuch (HGB) or German Commercial Code, plays a central role in shaping the financial reporting landscape for businesses operating in or with Germany. While German GAAP (HGB) and the International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) share common principles, they also differ in several key areas. This article provides an overview of the similarities, differences, and recent developments impacting German accounting practices and their relevance in international business.

HGB vs. IFRS: Key Similarities and Differences

Both HGB and IFRS use historical cost as the primary basis for accounting. However, the German approach under HGB is generally more conservative, with limited scope for asset revaluation. IFRS, in contrast, allows for the revaluation of assets such as property, plant, equipment, investment property, and intangible assets within specific industries.

Under German accounting law, exceptions exist, particularly for the fair value assessment of financial instruments held for trading by banks and financial institutions. These differences can affect asset valuation, financial ratios, and ultimately investment decisions.

Income Statement Presentation

The presentation of income statements under both frameworks shows some similarities but also notable distinctions:

• HGB does not provide for a statement of comprehensive income. Companies can present income using either the cost of sales method or the total cost method. Additionally, income derived from discounting provisions must be included alongside other interest income.
• IFRS offers more flexibility, allowing companies to present a single statement of comprehensive income or separate statements distinguishing profit or loss from other comprehensive income. IFRS 18, effective from 1 January 2027, will include new requirements for the classification of income and expenses and will require the presentation of new defined subtotals.

Cash Flow Statements

Under HGB, a statement of cash flows is mandatory only for:

• Consolidated financial statements.
• Publicly traded companies not required to file consolidated statements.

Both HGB and IFRS classify cash flows under operating, investing, and financing activities, but the frequency and format of disclosures can vary.

The Scope and Impact of HGB in International Business

The relevance of HGB extends beyond Germany’s borders. When international companies engage in contracts with German entities, they often specify the governing law—frequently HGB. This can influence:

• Contract terms and enforcement.
• Tax obligations and transfer pricing.
• Formation of joint ventures or subsidiaries.
• Appointment of commercial agents or distributors.

While HGB focuses primarily on business matters, consumer protection is governed by separate legal frameworks in Germany.

Enforcement and Compliance

HGB is enforced through:

• Civil litigation.
• Administrative oversight.
• Potential criminal penalties for serious violations.

Non-compliance can result in fines, legal claims, and reputational damage.

IFRS Adoption in Germany

Since the European Union’s IAS Regulation of 2002, IFRS has been the required standard for consolidated financial statements of companies listed on EU/EEA markets, effective from 2005. Germany, as an EU member state, adheres to this requirement.

Current German IFRS Adoption Status:

Recent and Ongoing Changes to HGB

Germany’s Commercial Code is evolving to reflect both EU directives and global trends in corporate reporting, sustainability, and digitalization. Here are the most significant developments:

1. Integrated Reporting

• Companies are increasingly required to integrate financial and non-financial information, particularly ESG (Environmental, Social, Governance) data, into their annual reports.

2. Digitalization of Reporting

• Annual financial reports must now be prepared in the European Single Electronic Format (ESEF) for companies listed on German markets, enhancing transparency and accessibility.

3. Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD)

• The CSRD mandates detailed sustainability disclosures using European Sustainability Reporting Standards (ESRS), reflecting the growing importance of ESG considerations in business.

4. Other Key Updates:

• Increased thresholds for company size classifications under HGB (effective from financial years beginning after December 31, 2023).
• Exemption from deferred tax recognition for certain minimum tax regulations.
• New disclosure requirements in the notes to the financial statements.
• Digital contract proof: From January 1, 2025, employers can provide contractual proof in electronic form.
• Digital tax audits: German tax authorities now permit encrypted digital meetings.

5. Role of the German Institute of Public Auditors (IDW)

• The IDW continues to issue updated standards, including guidance on partnership size classification (IDW RS FAB 7) and emission allowance accounting.
  
  

References

Deloitte IAS Plus . (2025). Germany . Retrieved from Deloitte IAS Plus : https://www.iasplus.com/en/jurisdictions/europe/germany

Green Vision Solutions . (2025, January 02). CSRD Implementation Act 2025 | The implementation of the CSRD in Germany. Retrieved from Green Vision Solutions : https://greenvisionsolutions.de/en/csrd-implementation-germany/

Kenton, W. (2024, May 01). Handelsgesetzbuch (HGB): The Commercial Code of Germany. Retrieved from Investopedia: https://www.investopedia.com/terms/h/hgb.asp

Nase, D. E., & Trotta, E. (2024). Corporate Governance Laws and Regulations Germany 2024-2025. ICLG.

Photo:
https://tse4.mm.bing.net/th/id/OIP.SNOObKi6vaGVSQbYWyMUAHaEi?rs=1&pid=ImgDetMain&o=7&rm=3